The Reliability Dilemma
Tuesday, December 8, 2026, – (America/New_York)
Level 2: Osprey 3 · Leadership for Reliability
The reliability dilemma - 90% of organizations are in a reactive mode of operations – this leads to unmanaged risks.
• Despite significant technical capability, use of RCM, AI etc, ‘human factors’ can lead to black swan events that can destroy company reputation
• Despite much progress on technical solutions that enable high reliability, the social and cultural aspects are not well understood
• Efforts to improve reliability via various process improvement techniques often backslide to reactive mode
• Major incidents reveal a repeating pattern that involves management failure and organizational culture as contributing root causes
• Managers become blind to risks, are overly focused on ‘shareholder value’ or other short-term targets, ignore warnings from employees, and exhibit autocratic behavior
• Retribution to those ‘whistleblowers,’ who are seen as ‘heretics,’ creates a ‘chilled atmosphere’ in the rest of the organization – leading to fatalism or apathy; this destroys frontline employees taking initiative to manage risks and eliminate defects
There are three primary root causes for the reliability dilemma:
1) Loss of primary aim, towards a what is only a means: profit and shareholder value
2) Firefighting traps that sustain reactive mode of operating
3) Dynamic complexity and lack of understanding of system level causes that impact reliability
Reliability culture is not a ‘nice to have’ – it is an ‘essential.’ The reliability community would benefit from greater understanding of the complex interactions between social and technical elements, and the journey from a reactive culture to a HRO.
A special kind of project can create a high reliability organization (HRO) and overcome the root causes that create the reliability dilemma.
HRO requires employee Ownership (with internal commitment to standards) at level ‘4’ or ‘5.’ Ownership leading to commitment is required because external compliance driven by audit will always miss non-conformances vs. requirements, and to foster ‘speak up culture’ by frontline employees to avoid errors of governance by supervisors.
Knowledge Level: Intermediate
Speakers
-
Director, Energy Transition Dynamics